10 mail order ice creams of 2022
Whether your best friend had a bad breakup or you can’t stop dreaming about that delicious frozen dessert you took on vacation last summer, there are plenty of benefits to ordering ice cream by mail. . As any true ice cream lover will tell you, it’s not just for the summer or even for dessert – any day can be a sundae if you believe in yourself.
Mail-order ice cream is a great option because you don’t have to worry about your favorite frozen confection melting in transit. While many national retailers use services like Instacart, Shipt, and Goldbelly to fulfill orders, some smaller businesses use FedEx to ship ice cream because they offer specialty insulated packaging to transport cold food. You can even send frozen food via USPS if your package meets its standards.
We’ve rounded up the ten best places to order ice cream online, so all you have to do is click, pay, and then wait patiently (or impatiently) outside the door for your next scoop. And when you’re between ice cream deliveries? Consider making a batch of homemade sweets. Check out our favorite ice cream makers, perfect for spinning those homemade ice cream recipes.
Our top picks
- Best Mail Order Ice Cream: Graeter ice cream
- Best Budget Mail-Order Ice Cream: A La Mode & Cooks Ice Cream Speed Bump
- Best Mail Order Ice Cream: Tipsy Scoop
- The most versatile mail-order ice cream: Malai Signature Ice Cream
- Best Dairy-Free Mail-Order Ice Cream: Crank & Boom Dairy Free Ice Cream Collection
- Best vegan ice cream by mail order: Non Dairy Nubocha Ice Cream
- Best Keto Mail Order Ice Cream: Rebel The Maverick Mixed Case Ice
- Best Mail Order Ice Cream Sandwiches: Babka La Newyorkina Ice Cream Sandwiches
- Best mail-order ice cream for a crowd: Original Rainbow Ice Cream Cake Roll
- Best mail-order ice cream for gifts: Life Raft Treats “No Fried Chicken” Ice Cream Bucket
How we chose these products
First, we identified the most popular mail-order ice creams. Next, we calculated shipping costs and methods and determined which ice cream delivery services actually save you money in the long run. We then took stock of factors such as overall price, availability, ingredients, flavors, and reviews from ice cream lovers themselves.
Advertising – Continue Reading Below
Best Mail Order Ice Cream
Graeter ice cream
- A classic
- Tons of flavors
Ice cream lovers may not be able to agree on a favorite flavor, but they can agree that Graeter’s is, well, excellent. Located in Cincinnati, Ohio, this fifth-generation, family-owned ice cream company has been in business since 1870, so it’s safe to say they know a thing or two about what makes great ice cream.
Among the many happy customers who sang the praises of this iconic store, one reviewer said their “shipment arrived safely, absolutely frozen,” while another exclaimed, “Oh my God! This is the best ice cream!”
Between the accolades and the wide range (there are 30 varieties in total!) of almost too rich flavors, this is a worthy foray into the world of ice cream delivery.
Best Budget Mail-Order Ice Cream
A La Mode & Cooks Ice Cream Speed Bump
- Very affordable
- Egg and nut free
Some reviewers liken this product to “homemade churned ice cream”, so it’s no surprise that A La Mode Speed Bump & Cooks Ice Cream is a hit with ice cream lovers.
This six-pack contains three pints each of their 3 Pints of Cooks (Vanilla Fudge Swirl with Chocolate and Vanilla Cookies) and Speed Bump (Dark Chocolate with Marshmallows and White Chocolate Chips) flavors and black), but you can also order packs of cotton candy and funfetti, vanilla and chocolate chip coffee, or classic chocolate and vanilla.
One customer said of these delicious treats, “These ice creams are well worth the price, and we appreciate A La Mode and their mission to make great treats without allergens. Highly recommended!”
That’s right, not only is this economical option a great choice for ice cream lovers, it’s also great for those with allergies to common ingredients, like eggs and nuts.
Best Splurge Mail Order Ice Cream
Scoop of Drunk Ice Cream
- Unique flavors
- Contains real alcohol
Infused with up to 5% ABV, Tipsy Scoop is “perfection in a pint,” according to a Goldbelly reviewer. “Delicious, smooth and creamy like ice cream should be. Alcohol is just right.”
“Ice cream delivered on the hottest day of the year (so far), 97 degrees,” said another reviewer. “[It] probably sat on my porch for 3 hours…and it was still freezing. On that note, we only have one thing to say: shut up and take our money!
The most versatile mail-order ice cream
Malai ice cream
Tired of the same old and boring ice cream flavors? Enter Malai Ice Cream, featuring over 30 regular and seasonal gourmet flavors – including Turkish Coffee, Rose with Cinnamon Roasted Almonds and Pink Peppercorn Pineapple – that are a cream eaters dream come true adventurous icy.
Ice cream aficionados came out of the woodwork to sing the company’s praises, with one reviewer saying “The six pints I ordered from [Malai Ice Cream] arrived still freezing cold and frozen solid. That’s great coming from New Y
ork west of North Carolina!”
In short, your biggest problem with this ice cream company will be deciding which pints to taste first.
Best Dairy Free Mail Order Ice Cream
Crank & Boom Dairy Free Ice Cream Collection
- Limited and rotating flavors
Since 2015, Crank & Boom’s “Ice Cream Parlor” in Lexington, KY has been providing delicious dairy and non-dairy desserts to an abundance of satisfied customers. It was even named “Best Ice Cream in Kentucky” by Travel & Leisure! Now anyone with a craving for smooth and creamy treats can enjoy this shop’s dairy-free ice cream collection, which is filled with dairy-free flavors like Chocolate Fudge Ripple, Cookies and No Cream, Coconut Caramel Delight, Banana and Chocolate, Strawberry Fields and their signature Bourbon and Honey.
One frosty fan said of this dairy-free dessert: “The ice cream has been packaged in such a way that it won’t melt. The quality of the ice cream is awesome. There is a range of flavors to choose from… [which allows] you to try something new.
Best Vegan Mail Order Ice Cream
Non Dairy Nubocha Ice Cream
- Excellent vegan option
- Also sugar and gluten free
Nubocha produces its dairy-free ice cream using simple ingredients and allulose, a diabetic-friendly sweetener. While it doesn’t offer a ton of flavors, each is vegan, gluten-free, and sugar-free.
Author, certified nutritionist and celebrity chef Liana Werner-Gray is among Amazon reviewers who are fans of these low-calorie treats (only 250-330 calories per pint!), saying, “The consistency and flavor…are on point, and…I also like that Nubocha uses pure cocoa instead of processed chocolate.”
Best Mail Order Keto Ice Cream
The Maverick Mixed Case Ice Cream
- Great keto-friendly substitute
- Some texture issues
- You have to thaw first
Sure, there are plenty of keto recipes out there to satisfy your other cravings, but what happens when your sweet tooth starts craving ice cream? If you feel the craving… the craving for sweets… Maverick Mixed Case Ice Cream is the keto-friendly substitute you need. It comes with a pint of cookies and cream, salted caramel, black raspberry, triple chocolate, cherry chips, coconut swirl, peanut butter fudge and, of course, vanilla.
One verified Amazon buyer called this “great [keto-friendly] ice cream,” explaining, “It tastes like ice cream, [is] filling, it tastes sweet and the flavors are great.
Best Mail Order Ice Cream Sandwiches
Babka La Newyorkina Ice Cream Sandwiches
- Great cake/ice cream combo
- delicious taste
What’s better than cake and ice cream? We sure can’t think of just one, which is why we’re so grateful Fany Gerson, founder of Brooklyn-based La Newyorkina, developed the heavenly Babka Ice Cream Sandwiches. Available in chocolate, vanilla or a half-and-half mix, these DIY kits are sure to delight, with reviewers calling this frozen dish ‘delicious’ with ‘great flavor’.
It doesn’t matter whether you choose this six-pack for a group or keep them all to yourself – these babies can be stored frozen for up to three weeks, giving you plenty of time to put a dent in your supply.
Best Mail Order Ice Cream for a Crowd
Original Rainbow Ice Cream Cake Roll
- Multiple complementary flavors
Birthdays, graduations, baby showers – no matter what you’re celebrating, there’s no party like an ice cream party, especially if the Original Rainbow Cone Ice Cream Cake Roll is on the menu.
After several (tortuous, we’re sure) taste tests, the owners of Chicago’s infamous Rainbow Cone ice cream shop settled on the ultimate flavor combination: chocolate, strawberry, pistachio almond, orange sherbet, and Palmer House, aka vanilla with cherries and nuts. . And now you and up to 8 guests can reap the rewards of their search.
This is certainly a popular item among Goldbelly customers, with one saying their “ice cream was rock solid on arrival, although [the] the dry ice was almost gone.”
Best Mail Order Ice Cream for Gifts
Life Raft Treats “No Fried Chicken” Ice Cream Bucket
- Comes with 9 pieces
- Black-owned business
Think about it: would you rather give the ice cream (or chicken) lover in your life regular old cupcakes, or a truly memorable and memorable gift like this “No Fried Chicken” ice cream bucket?
We think the answer is clear, but if you need more convincing, consider this reviewer’s experience: “Absolutely everything went well!” Even though the delivery was on the doorstep of a hot FL for over an hour, there was still dry ice in the cooler, keeping our “chicken wings” perfectly cold.”
This content is created and maintained by a third party, and uploaded to this page to help users provide their email addresses. You may be able to find more information about this and similar content on piano.io
Advertising – Continue Reading Below